Serving Authentic Italian Cuisine, Scratch Made Brick Oven Pizza in Historic Sackets Harbor NY.

Who We Are

Good Fellos is pleased to provide you and your guests with an exceptional, relaxed setting in the heart of the scenic village of Sackets Harbor, NY.

We have been serving authentic Italian cuisine, scratch-made brick oven pizza, a creative Sunday brunch, and a full-service wine bar in the warm, intimate atmosphere of a tastefully renovated historic building for about 20 years. 

We are known for our exceptional customer service, fresh ingredients, excellent selection of wines and a unique atmosphere that is unmatched.

Our Wine


Choose from one of 50 hand-selected bottles of wine on the wine menu at our cozy, full service bar, or from one of the 16 local or regional microbreweries on tap. 

If you are in the mood for something new, our friendly, knowledgeable staff is always ready to help you pair your wine with your entree or will suggest one of our signature cocktails for you to try.

Every Wednesday we have the best cure for the mid-week blues with our popular Wine Night starting at 4 pm, featuring $2 glasses of wine!


Relax with family and friends, and get your week started on a positive note with our innovative Sunday Brunch menu prepared by Chef Steve. We are one of the only restaurants in the area serving Brunch every Sunday from 10am - 3pm - rain, shine or snow.

Sit in our comfortable booths next to our tall, picture windows, sip on one of famous Mimosas or Bloody Mary’s, and take in the warm, comforting atmosphere that is Good Fellos.

Good Fellos Pizza

Upcoming Events
Sunday Brunch Sunday
10:00 AM
See our terrific and new brunch menu above. A great way to spend your Sunday with friends and family.
Wine Night Wednesday
4:00 PM
The Original local wine night! Enjoy our house wines, only $2 a glass or $8 a bottle. Our prices have remained the same for a dozen years. Come enjoy our cozy fun atmosphere and bring your friends.